914.946.0848  .  contact  .  map & directions  .  subscribe  . 

Are there Limits to Client Self-Determination? Part 2

September 29, 2015  | 
Are there Limits to Client Self-Determination?  Part 2 by Clare Piro

{3:36 minutes to read} In a previous post, I discussed the difficulty faced by a mediator when he or she needs to consider whether or not the client’s right to self-determination should be controlling in the face of an agreement that could be considered unconscionable.

In my initial consultation with clients, I try to draw the distinction for them between someone who:

  • Is unable to fully participate in the mediation;

  • Does not have the capacity to mediate or

  • Cannot advocate for himself or herself.

Versus someone who:

  • Has the capacity to make decisions;

  • Is an advocate;

  • Is a full participant in the mediation process.

Lacks the Capacity to Mediate

The first type of client could include someone who is the victim of domestic violence or is unable to advocate due to mental illness or substance abuse. While these matters might be mediated with the proper safeguards and a trained mediator, they present challenges that need to be addressed. If these challenges cannot be overcome, then the parties should not mediate and should seek a dispute resolution forum which would provide the support and protections they require.

Has the Capacity to Mediate

Here, I draw the distinction between what might be viewed as a decision most people would think is contrary to law versus a decision that most people would think is unconscionable and one which would render the Agreement unenforceable if challenged.

For example, in the former, I explain that I am not talking about the garden variety case where for whatever reason, one party is willing to give more than what might customarily be considered the norm, such as a party waiving the right to a particular asset, or paying or receiving more or less than what is generally accepted in terms of support. In those cases, the decision does not render either party destitute. As long as they are fully informed, I believe a client has the absolute right to make these decisions, even if I believe them to be poor ones.

On the other hand, when clients agree to terms that would not be upheld by the Court if the Agreement is challenged because the terms are so grossly unfair, I tell my clients that while I respect their right to self-determination, it does no good for them if I draft an agreement under those circumstances.

Should that be the case, I tell clients that I would not draft an agreement unless they have consulted with attorneys. I would require this not just for the benefit of the person who would be giving up significant rights but also for the benefit of the other party. If the Agreement is likely to be challenged and may be found to be so unconscionable as to be rescinded, it does not serve either party’s ultimate purpose.
Clare Piro Attorney and Mediator

Attorney & Mediator
500 Mamaroneck Avenue | Suite 320
Harrison, NY 10528
Tel: 914.946.0848

Email »

Comments
Search
Topics
Mediation (74) | Divorce (72) | Divorce Mediation (17) | Mediator (13) | Conflict (9) | Litigation (8) | Child Support (8) | Separation Agreement (7) | Consultation (6) | Clare A. Piro Mediation (6) | Clare A. Piro (6) | Collaborative Divorce (6) | Separation (5) | Family (4) | Children (4) | Settlement (4) | Communication (4) | Parenting (4) | Attorney (4) | Finances (4) | Expenses (3) | Clare Piro (3) | Divorce And Children (3) | Equitable Distribution (3) | Marital Assets (3) | Clients (3) | Child Support Standards Act (3) | Agreement (2) | Marital Home (2) | Child Support Standards Act (CSSA) (2) | Truth (2) | Compromise (2) | Moving Forward (2) | Divorce Mediator (2) | Mediate (2) | College Expenses (2) | Spouse (2) | Marital Property (2) | Apology (2) | Legislation (2) | Custody (2) | Separate Property (2) | Seperation (2) | Conflict During Mediation (2) | Bitterness (2) | Anger (2) | Parenting Plan (2) | Couples (2) | Certified Divorce Financial Analyst (CDFA) (2) | Unrequited Love (2) | Divorce Finances (2) | Informed Decisions (2) | CSSA (2) | Calculating Support (2) | Post-Divorce Income (2) | Step-Mother (2) | Assets (2) | Relationships (2) | Settlement Agreements (2) | Mediation Versus Litigation (2) | Mediation Benefits (2) | Step-Children (2) | Mediation Myths (2) | Step-Father (2) | Separation Agreements (1) | Blended Families (1) | Anxiety (1) | MediationSession (1) | LawyerDivorceMediation (1) | FamilyMediation (1) | AttorneyPresence (1) | Perfection (1) | Matrimonial Dispute (1) | Work Stress (1) | Holiday Preparations (1) | Bankruptcy (1) | Dreaming (1) | Intervention (1) | Custodial Parent (1) | Financial Situation (1) | Therapy (1) | Beneficiary (1) | Settlement Term (1) | Life Insurance (1) | Spousal Support (1) | Husband (1) | Wife (1) | Lies (1) | Little White Lies (1) | Dishonest (1) | Public Trust (1) | Personal Relationships (1) | Affair (1) | Married (1) | Settlement Agreement (1) | Spouses (1) | Reluctant Spouse (1) | Negotiation (1) | Entitlement (1) | Needs Vs Wants (1) | Court Vs Mediation (1) | Emotions (1) | Court Process (1) | Financial Documents (1) | Mental Health Professional (1) | Family Law Software (1) | Financial Information (1) | Budgets (1) | Prenup (1) | Prenuptial Agreement (1) | But (1) | Financial Professional (1) | Apologizing (1) | Equitable Distribution Statute (1) | Property Distribution (1) | Fiancé (1) | Prenuptial Agreement (Prenup) (1) | Marital Concerns (1) | Asset Distribution (1) | Attitudes Toward Prenups (1) | Collaborative Process (1) | Lawyer (1) | Fear Of Separation (1) | Emotional Attachment (1) | Dividing House Asset (1) | Divorce Assets (1) | Refinance (1) | Equity Loan (1) | Ex-Spouse (1) | Accepting Responsibility (1) | Attitudes (1) | Family Enrichment (1) | Remarriage After Divorce (1) | Taking Responsibility (1) | Interest Payments (1) | Cash Flow (1) | Patience (1) | Time To Process (1) | Post Nuptial (1) | PostNup (1) | Marriage Counseling (1) | Frame Of Mind (1) | Buyer (1) | Seller (1) | Telling Your Spouse (1) | Divorce Coach (1) | Significant Other (1) | Nesting (1) | Year In Review (1) | 2015 (1) | Blame (1) | Advice (1) | Mindfulness (1) | Equality (1) | Self Determination (1) | New York State (1) | Control (1) | Balance (1) | Self-talk (1) | New York (1) | Listening (1) | Effects On Family (1) | Living Together (1) | Living Apart (1) | Older Dogs (1) | Adopt Shelter Dogs (1) | Budget (1) | Agreements (1) | Dogs (1) | Self-determination (1) | Difficult Clients (1) | Halloween (1) | Fear Of Divorce (1) | Scared Of Divorce (1) | Holiday Blues (1) | Moving On After Divorce (1) | Joint Physical Custody (1) | Parenting Plans (1) | Co-Parenting (1) | Parenting Post-Divorce (1) | Holidays Post-Divorce (1) | Alone At The Holidays (1) | Mental Health (1) | Specialist (1) | Relocation (1) | Change (1) | Equity (1) | House (1) | Consulting Attorney (1) | Post-Divorce Dating (1) | Finding Love After Divorce (1) | Baby Boomers (1) | Grandparents (1) | Maritial Property (1) | Maritial Assets (1) | Retirement Account (1) | Divorce Papers (1) | Transmutation (1) | Commingling (1) | Compassion (1) | Hurricane Harvey (1) | Married Couples (1) | Negative Communication (1) | Joint Decision Making (1) | Accusations Of Delay (1) | Lack Of Trust (1) | Financial Costs (1) | Joint Account (1) | Tentative Agreements (1) | Permanent Agreement (1) | Joint Legal Custody (1) | Installment Agreements (1) | Temporary Agreement (1) | College (1) | Contribution (1) | Summer (1) | Kids (1) | School Year (1) | Power (1) | Marriage (1) | Resolution (1) | Divorce Law (1) | Abundance (1) | Scarcity (1) | Acknowledgement (1) | Conflicy (1) | Responsibility (1) | Moving On (1) | Disclosure (1) | Parents (1) | Unemployment (1) | Seperation Agreement (1) | Fall (1) | Extremes (1) | Payments (1) | Settle Agreement (1) |
Connect